« Happy Palm Sunday | Main | Iran »
April 12, 2006
Some Good News
Thought I'd link to a couple news stories that brought some warmth to this social justice advocate's heart. The first regards questions before several courts about the potential cruelty of lethal injection. Given that this method is often assumed by far the most un-cruel form of capital punishment, maybe we're making our way to a moratorium on the death sentence in a few states. Certainly would be nice. Also heartening about the story was that the uber-conservative AMA is insisting on the violation of physicians' ethical standards by assisting or attending lethal injections. It seems some judges are looking to mandate the presence of doctors if lethal injection is going to be considered un-cruel, but doctors really can't do that. (I guess they really did want us to take the "do no harm" part of the oath seriously!) Physicians might find themselves in a position to take a stand on a very important pro-life issue. Let's hope they find the courage to do so.
Also, there was a glimmer of hope in immigration talk; read here. While there is still a lot to be concerned about, at least the hardline anti-immigrant types have backed off on making it a felony to enter the country illegally. Hopefully the bible-thumping zealots who use Leviticus to "protect" marriage will not neglect Leviticus 19:33-34.
Posted by mattalexander at April 12, 2006 11:19 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.justenough.org/mt/traX0r_me.cgi/238
Comments
So how does the 'do no harm' thing fit into physician-assisted suicide?
Posted by: kal at April 12, 2006 2:26 PM
Um... Yeah, I've never been to impressed with arguments in favor of it. The idea, a la Oregon, is that the physician does not impose the harmful means that end a life. Rather, they provide access. However, I still don't find it compelling that a physician is not doing harm by providing a prescription for a bunch of morphine knowing full well the patient is going to end his or her life. Frankly, this capital punishment business involving physicians suprised me because it's my impression that some doctors don't take "do no harm" that seriously and easily support abortion and assisted suicide. Just curious, but how common is opposition to the death penalty among pro-lifers you interact with? Lack of a voice on that and a complacency with war from those circles seems very puzzling to me. (I realize I hold a different ontology, epistemology, and politics than most of them, so it's understandable. I'm just curious.)
Posted by: Matt at April 12, 2006 5:25 PM
Well, CPLC and the other state affiliates of National Right to Life don't take a position on capital punishment. The pro-life issue is so often wrapped up in religion and other conservative issues (i.e. gay marraige, evolution), that we as an organization make a point of staying strictly within the issues of abortion, euthanasia, infanticide, and embryonic experimentation and being non-sectarian. For some reason quoting the bible just doesn't rake in the votes...
Interestingly enough, we just had the state finals of our Teen Oratory Contest, and one student presented a speech that equivocated abortion and capital punishment as two sides of the same coin. It was kind of out of left field, as we simply don't address that issue, but a good speech. Many of his sources were Catholic in origin, which gave me the impression that more of the Catholic pro-lifers are opposed to capital punishment, while the others, your protestant-conservative-homeschooling pro-lifers are more likely to favor it in the same way they support the war. Unfortunately, i don't think they see the conflict in opposing abortion but supporting capital punishment and war. They've come to believe that 'Freedom' is just as biblical as Life, so thus are the methods of defending it, domestically and overseas. Hard to make a blanket statement for all pro-lifers though. i'd like to believe some are smart enough to think it through.
i had interesting conversation with an affiliate the other day about how teachers' unions are notoriously pro-choice, which is pretty foolish if you think about it. Over 40 million students have been aborted in the last 33 years...you'd think they'd be a little more concerned about job security. :)
Posted by: kal at April 13, 2006 3:21 PM

